Best of 21 pizza in Carlton
Maria Luchici
• Updated: 2025-03-02Pizza in Carlton Melbourne is a culinary delight that tantalizes taste buds with its diverse offerings. From traditional Italian pizzas to modern interpretations, Carlton's pizza scene caters to every palate. Experience the authentic flavors of Italy at renowned pizzerias, or venture off the beaten path to discover hidden gems serving innovative creations. Whether you prefer classic Margherita or adventurous toppings, Carlton's pizza will leave you craving for more.
Table of Contents
- 1. DOC Pizza & Mozzarella Bar - Carlton
- 2. Leonardo's Pizza Palace
- 3. Capitano Carlton
- 4. Gemma Simply Italian
- 5. Kaprica
- 6. Il Carretto Pizza
- 7. Toto's Pizza House
- 8. Di Stasio Carlton
- 9. Carlton Pizzeria
- 10. Tiamo
- 11. Il Gambero
- 12. Domino's Pizza Carlton (vic)
- 13. Café Corretto – Ferrari Restaurant
- 14. Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria
- 15. Joanne's Pizzeria
- 16. Papa Gino's
- 17. Criniti's Carlton
- 18. Cafe Cavallino
- 19. Veloce Pizza Bar
- 20. Intersection Cafe
- 21. Seasons Provedore
1.DOC Pizza & Mozzarella Bar - Carlton
Authentic Italian flavors in a cozy atmosphere.
Don’t miss the chance to savor the iconic pizza Margherita and heavenly calzones, each crafted with passion and precision. As you round off your meal, treat yourself to the velvety tiramisu, creamy gelato, and delightful flija—desserts that promise to elevate your dining experience to extraordinary heights. Come and discover why this culinary gem is the talk of the town!
2.Leonardo's Pizza Palace
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with love and fresh ingredients!
Is this the pinnacle of pizza in Melbourne? Absolutely! Each dish is a testament to culinary artistry, crafted with love and precision. The cocktails are equally impressive, enhancing the dining experience with their delightful flavors. If you find yourself in Melbourne, make it a priority to visit Leonardo’s Pizza Palace; it’s a culinary gem that promises to elevate your dining experience to new heights. Don’t just take our word for it—experience the magic for yourself!
3.Capitano Carlton
Authentic Italian flavors in a cozy atmosphere.
The menu boasts a tantalizing array of options, but the standout for me was the vodka sauce pasta, an absolute delight with its al dente perfection. And let’s not overlook the square pizzas; they are a revelation! Light and fluffy, these pies are a delightful fusion of pizza and focaccia. The Sicilian version, adorned with capers and olives, was a treat for the senses. With spacious seating and a welcoming ambiance, Capitano is undoubtedly a top contender for the best pizza spot in town.
4.Gemma Simply Italian
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with passion and tradition.
Our curiosity piqued, we couldn’t resist the allure of Lygon Street, renowned for its Italian culinary delights. The scene was a feast for the eyes, with colorful pizzas being shared and enjoyed, each one a masterpiece of taste and craftsmanship. It was clear that this was not just a meal but an experience waiting to unfold, inviting us to indulge in the rich tapestry of flavors that only a true Italian pizzeria can offer.
5.Kaprica
Savor the taste of locally sourced ingredients in every bite!
Though the location may have evolved, one truth remains: the pizzas here are simply unmatched. Witness the artistry and passion that unfolds in the kitchen, where each pizza is crafted with meticulous care. Once you experience the explosion of flavors and textures, you'll understand why this gem ranks among Melbourne's finest culinary treasures. Treat yourself to a slice of heaven that you won't soon forget!
6.Il Carretto Pizza
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with love and fresh ingredients.
While the food shines with standout offerings like the exquisite spaghetti marinara, the absence of a full spirits menu may leave some diners wanting. However, the charm of Il Carretto lies in its authentic Italian roots, making it a must-visit for anyone exploring Melbourne. Whether you're a local or a traveler, this gem promises a genuine taste of Italy that you won't soon forget. Discover the magic of Italian cuisine and create unforgettable memories at Il Carretto!
7.Toto's Pizza House
Authentic Italian flavors with fresh ingredients, perfect for pizza lovers!
Our evening unfolded with a delightful array of dishes, from bruschetta to chicken Parma, though the bruschetta left us wanting more of its signature tomatoes amidst a sea of prosciutto. The highlight, however, was the medium pizza we shared—half and half at no extra charge—and the house-made gnocchi that stole the show. Each bite of that gnocchi was a revelation, undeniably the best I've ever tasted! Come savor these flavors and rediscover the magic of Italian cuisine.
8.Di Stasio Carlton
Authentic Italian cuisine with a modern twist, perfect for every occasion.
In stark contrast, there's an absolute gem of an Italian eatery that beckons food lovers with its enchanting outdoor courtyard, perfect for basking in the sun during a leisurely afternoon or celebrating special occasions. The 'Feed Me' menu offers a tantalizing selection of dishes that promises to delight. Having dined at both the Carlton and City locations, I can confidently say that the warm service and vibrant atmosphere make this one of my favorite dining spots in Melbourne, especially on a balmy summer day.
9.Carlton Pizzeria
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with fresh, local ingredients.
At Carlton Pizzeria, every meal is a celebration of authentic Italian flavors, designed to transport you straight to the heart of Italy. Whether you're dining in or taking out, the experience promises to delight your palate and leave you craving more. Treat yourself to a culinary adventure that combines tradition with a modern twist—your taste buds will thank you!
10.Tiamo
Authentic Italian cuisine with a cozy atmosphere and fresh ingredients.
Having frequented this restaurant over the years, it has become our beloved go-to for genuine Italian cuisine. Our Italian friend was so enchanted by the ambiance and flavors that she declared it felt just like home. The hearty meals are worth every penny, and the friendly service ensures a memorable dining experience. Just a heads-up: on busy weekends, it's wise to make a reservation, as this gem tends to fill up quickly. However, the cleanliness of the restroom could use some attention, as it slightly detracted from an otherwise delightful outing.
11.Il Gambero
Authentic Italian cuisine made with love and fresh ingredients.
The highlight of the meal was undeniably the pasta, served hot and bursting with flavor, all at an incredibly reasonable price. We indulged in a refreshing salad, but next time, I’ll opt for the main size to truly satisfy my appetite. Each bite, from the antipasto to the tantalizing desserts, was a testament to the kitchen's talent. The Nutella dessert, in particular, was a heavenly conclusion to our feast—too tempting to resist!
12.Domino's Pizza Carlton (vic)
Freshly made pizzas delivered hot and fast to your door!
If you're looking for a quick and satisfying meal that everyone will love, pizza is the ultimate choice. Whether it’s a family reunion, a corporate lunch, or a casual get-together with friends, these delectable slices offer a fantastic way to please a crowd without breaking the bank. So, why settle for anything less when you can serve up a spread that’s both convenient and irresistibly tasty?
13.Café Corretto – Ferrari Restaurant
Authentic Italian cuisine with a modern twist, perfect for every occasion.
Later that night, after an exhilarating performance at Her Majesty's Theatre, hunger struck again. As we strolled along the street, we stumbled upon this charming café, which stood out for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly patrons. We ordered a large pizza to share among the three of us, and within just 15 minutes, our delicious creation arrived. While it may not have been the culinary revelation I expected, the quality ingredients shone through, especially the tender chicken. Priced at $27, it may not be the ultimate bargain, but the experience and flavors made it a delightful late-night find.
14.Mercadante Woodfired Pizzeria
Authentic woodfired pizzas made with fresh, local ingredients.
Nestled among the bustling Italian eateries on Lygon Street, Mercadante shines with its inviting ambiance and a menu that caters to every palate. The charm of this restaurant lies not just in its food, but in the genuine warmth of its staff. Their playful banter and attentive service create an atmosphere where laughter and joy abound. From celebrating special occasions to engaging with families, the team at Mercadante knows how to make every diner feel special, leaving a lasting impression that beckons us to return time and again.
15.Joanne's Pizzeria
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with fresh, local ingredients.
While my salad fell short of expectations, the attentive staff swiftly addressed my concerns, showcasing their commitment to exceptional service. This pizzeria stands unparalleled in its dedication to quality, making it my top recommendation for any pizza enthusiast. When the topic of pizza arises, this gem is the only name you need to remember!
16.Papa Gino's
Delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and a family-friendly atmosphere.
Every bite at Papa's Gino is a celebration of taste, transporting you straight to Italy with its warm ambiance and delectable offerings. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or a pasta lover, this eatery promises a feast that tantalizes the senses. Don’t miss out on the chance to savor their mouthwatering dishes that combine quality and affordability. Your next memorable meal is just a reservation away!
17.Criniti's Carlton
Authentic Italian dining experience with a modern twist.
On the service front, the restaurant has faced criticism for its disorganization and communication barriers, leading to frustrating dining experiences. Patrons have reported long waits for their meals and a lack of responsiveness from staff, which can turn an anticipated meal into a disappointing affair. While some guests have enjoyed the food, the inconsistency in service and flavor may leave you questioning whether Criniti's is worth the visit amidst Melbourne's vibrant dining scene.
18.Cafe Cavallino
Experience authentic Italian flavors in a cozy atmosphere.
After five visits, I can confidently say Cafe Cavallino reigns supreme among Italian eateries. The spaghetti is a symphony of flavors, while the traditional pizza is worthy of five stars. The inviting atmosphere and delightful staff only enhance the experience, making each meal a memorable occasion. Having explored various spots along Lygon St, I’ve found my favorite here, and I highly recommend it to anyone seeking exceptional value and mouthwatering dishes. Don’t miss out on this culinary treasure!
19.Veloce Pizza Bar
Authentic Italian flavors crafted with fresh, local ingredients.
Don’t miss your chance to experience the magic of Veloce Pizza Bar! With an inviting atmosphere and a menu that tantalizes the taste buds, it’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a lively gathering with friends. Reserve your table today and embark on a delicious journey through Italy right in the heart of Melbourne. Your unforgettable feast awaits!
20.Intersection Cafe
A cozy spot for coffee lovers and brunch enthusiasts.
Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch between classes or unwinding with friends, Intersection Cafe is the place to be. The lively atmosphere and mouthwatering menu make it a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a satisfying meal. Treat yourself to a culinary adventure that promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you coming back for more!
21.Seasons Provedore
Experience authentic Italian flavors in a cozy atmosphere.
But don’t stop there—dive into the allure of their wood-fired pizzas, where the magic truly happens. Each pie emerges from the oven with a tantalizing smoky essence and a satisfyingly crisp crust, creating a delightful contrast to the rich toppings. This culinary masterpiece is not just a dish; it’s a gastronomic adventure waiting to be savored. Treat yourself to a slice of heaven at Seasons Provedore, where every pizza tells a story of passion and quality.